This article is a reflective essay that assesses the strength of comments made by Christopher L. Tomlins in his book The State and Unions (1985), which looks back over the past quarter century. Various predictions were made concerning union decline and failed revival efforts as well as counterfeit rights offered to the U.S. working class.

QUESTION

Locate the following article in the Business Source Ultimate database in the CSU Online Library:

Hurd, R. W. (2013). Moving beyond the critical synthesis: Does the law preclude a future for US unions? Labor History, 54(2), 193-200.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Essay on
This article is a reflective essay that assesses the strength of comments made by Christopher L. Tomlins in his book The State and Unions (1985), which looks back over the past quarter century. Various predictions were made concerning union decline and failed revival efforts as well as counterfeit rights offered to the U.S. working class.
Get a plagiarism free paperJust from $13/Page
Order Essay

This article is a reflective essay that assesses the strength of comments made by Christopher L. Tomlins in his book The State and Unions (1985), which looks back over the past quarter century. Various predictions were made concerning union decline and failed revival efforts as well as counterfeit rights offered to the U.S. working class.

Using all of the knowledge accumulated in this unit and in previous units, write a critique of the article. You may use other academic resources to support your points as necessary. Your critique must be at least three pages in length.

Your critique should address the questions below.

Be sure to follow the guidelines below.

  • Accurately identify the premise and supporting points from the article.
  • Provide an insightful and thorough analysis of the information from the article, including using evidence as well as reasonable and compelling interpretations.
  • Link material to course content and real-world situations.
  • Organize the material logically by using smooth transitions and by grouping similar material together.
  • Cite all sources used; paraphrased and quoted material must have accompanying citations in APA format.

ANSWER

Critique of “Moving beyond the Critical Synthesis: Does the Law Preclude a Future for US Unions?” by Hurd, R. W.

Introduction

In the article “Moving beyond the Critical Synthesis: Does the Law Preclude a Future for US Unions?” by R. W. Hurd, the author reflects on Christopher L. Tomlins’ book “The State and Unions” (1985) and examines the predictions and arguments made regarding the decline of unions and the challenges faced by the U.S. working class. This critique will analyze the main points presented by the author, assess the supporting arguments, evaluate the evidence provided, discuss collective bargaining strategies, and offer an opinion on the article.

Main Points

Assessing the strength of Christopher L. Tomlins’ comments: The author aims to critically evaluate the arguments made by Tomlins in his book, particularly regarding the decline of unions and the limited rights provided to the U.S. working class.

Predictions of union decline and failed revival efforts: Hurd discusses Tomlins’ predictions about the future of unions and the challenges they face, questioning whether the law hinders the possibility of a successful union resurgence.

Supporting Arguments

The author presents several arguments to support the main points:

Historical analysis: Hurd provides a historical perspective on the labor movement, citing past challenges faced by unions and the impact of legal frameworks on their ability to organize and protect workers’ rights.

Legal constraints: The author highlights the legal barriers faced by unions, such as restrictive labor laws and anti-union practices employed by employers, which have hindered union growth and weakened their bargaining power.

Counterfeit rights: Hurd discusses Tomlins’ argument that the New Deal era offered only superficial or counterfeit liberties to labor, suggesting that these limited rights had a negative effect on employee morale and the overall strength of the labor movement.

Evidence to Support the Main Point

The author draws upon historical evidence, legal analyses, and scholarly perspectives to support the main point:

Historical case studies: Hurd references historical examples of union struggles, such as the decline of industrial unionism and the impact of the Taft-Hartley Act, to support the argument that legal factors have influenced union decline.

Legal analysis: The author examines labor laws and their implications on union organizing and collective bargaining rights, providing evidence that legal frameworks have posed challenges to union growth and effectiveness.

Collective Bargaining Strategies and Employee Morale

Two collective bargaining strategies companies use when dealing with unions are:

Oppositional approach: Employers may adopt an adversarial stance, employing aggressive tactics to undermine union organizing efforts, including anti-union campaigns, hiring union-busting consultants, and implementing strategies to delay or obstruct bargaining processes. This approach can negatively impact employee morale by creating a hostile work environment and eroding trust between management and workers.

Cooperative approach: Some companies choose to engage in cooperative bargaining, fostering a mutually beneficial relationship with unions. This strategy involves open communication, collaboration, and a focus on shared goals. A cooperative approach can enhance employee morale by promoting a sense of fairness, employee involvement, and job security.

Opinion of the Article

In my opinion, the article provides a thought-provoking analysis of the challenges faced by unions and the impact of legal constraints on their ability to organize and advocate for workers’ rights. The author effectively questions Tomlins’ arguments and offers valuable insights into the complexities of the labor movement in the United States.

Supporting Evidence

Additional sources and the textbook provide supporting evidence for my opinion:

Textbook references: The textbook likely covers topics related to labor history, collective bargaining, and the challenges faced by unions, which can provide a broader understanding of the issues discussed in the article.

Scholarly articles: Reputable academic sources analyzing union decline, labor laws, and the impact on employee morale can offer further insights and evidence to support or challenge the arguments presented in the article.

Conclusion

In “Moving beyond the Critical Synthesis: Does the Law Preclude a Future for US Unions?” by R. W. Hurd, the author critically examines the arguments put forth by Christopher L. Tomlins regarding the decline of unions and the challenges faced by the U.S. working class. Through historical analysis and legal perspectives, the author highlights the influence of legal constraints on unions’ ability to organize effectively. The article prompts readers to consider the complex interplay between labor laws, collective bargaining strategies, and employee morale. Overall, this critique appreciates the author’s efforts to shed light on the state of unions and the role of the law in shaping their future.

Homework Valley
Calculate your paper price
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Our Advantages

Plagiarism Free Papers

All our papers are original and written from scratch. We will email you a plagiarism report alongside your completed paper once done.

Free Revisions

All papers are submitted ahead of time. We do this to allow you time to point out any area you would need revision on, and help you for free.

Title-page

A title page preceeds all your paper content. Here, you put all your personal information and this we give out for free.

Bibliography

Without a reference/bibliography page, any academic paper is incomplete and doesnt qualify for grading. We also offer this for free.

Originality & Security

At Homework Valley, we take confidentiality seriously and all your personal information is stored safely and do not share it with third parties for any reasons whatsoever. Our work is original and we send plagiarism reports alongside every paper.

24/7 Customer Support

Our agents are online 24/7. Feel free to contact us through email or talk to our live agents.

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

We work around the clock to see best customer experience.

Pricing

Flexible Pricing

Our prices are pocket friendly and you can do partial payments. When that is not enough, we have a free enquiry service.

Communication

Admission help & Client-Writer Contact

When you need to elaborate something further to your writer, we provide that button.

Deadlines

Paper Submission

We take deadlines seriously and our papers are submitted ahead of time. We are happy to assist you in case of any adjustments needed.

Reviews

Customer Feedback

Your feedback, good or bad is of great concern to us and we take it very seriously. We are, therefore, constantly adjusting our policies to ensure best customer/writer experience.